PCEngineFans.com - The PC Engine and TurboGrafx-16 Community Forum
NEC TG-16/TE/TurboDuo => TG-16/TE/TurboDuo Discussion => Topic started by: DarkKobold on June 02, 2012, 09:55:24 AM
Title: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on June 02, 2012, 09:55:24 AM
Hi all! I've made quite a few turbografx Tool-Assisted Speedruns; It turned me into quite the TG-16 fan. I joined this forum when I finally got TG-16 stuff, but I figured I'd share some of the runs I've done in the past:
Dungeon Explorer (uses 5 players!): http://tasvideos.org/1645M.html
Shockman: http://tasvideos.org/1690M.html
Bloody Wolf: http://tasvideos.org/1703M.html
Legend of Hero Tonma: http://tasvideos.org/1683M.html
I also made a Neutopia 2 TAS, but never got it published:
I realize some people aren't a fan of TASes, but some people on this forum might enjoy these. To those who don't know what TASes are, please look at this: http://tasvideos.org/WelcomeToTASVideos.html
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: fraggore on June 07, 2012, 10:48:23 AM
cool will give them a watch love speed runs.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 23, 2012, 07:25:41 PM
Bump for esteban
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: tggodfrey on October 24, 2012, 04:28:04 AM
Nice job.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: hizaygizirlz on October 24, 2012, 09:26:21 AM
i watched a few levels of DE. That was pretty interesting. Those bosses get rocked w/ 5 characters shooting at them.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Drakon on October 24, 2012, 03:39:39 PM
I love tas! It's a great way to preview a game. And it's also fun to see how you can abuse games.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Arkhan on October 25, 2012, 04:18:53 AM
Dammit, DK. Now I want to learn to make these and play through the whole US TG16/CD library, but there's no way in hell I'll have time for the next few years. Thanks a lot! lol... no, really... I didn't know TAS existed until this thread, and since I have very little time for games, this is a good way for me to experience a lot of games in a little time. So, thanks a lot!
You don't experience a damn thing if you TAS through the game.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 04:35:12 AM
Why cant you simply enjoy doing a second run, optimizing your skill and clear time, without said cheating and exploits, thus improving game skills, and do videos of that instead?
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 05:03:42 AM
I don't rely on FAQ's and the internet for anything in general, other then if I need a move list for a fighting game. Otherwise I go it alone.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 25, 2012, 05:28:36 AM
Why cant you simply enjoy doing a second run, optimizing your skill and clear time, without said cheating and exploits, thus improving game skills, and do videos of that instead?
Why not both?
TASVideos has a sister community, SpeedDemosArchive, which is about people doing exactly that. Neither community feels that one invalidates the need for the other. In fact, I've been practicing Dungeon Explorer. Got my lowest time of 27:30 recently.
Anyway, TASes aren't cheating. This topic has been beaten to death in other spots on the internet. Some people get it, others don't. If you don't like them, that is cool. 'nuff people do.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 05:34:35 AM
When you beat a game by using cheatcodes, save states, exploits, etc, its called cheating, so don't sit there trying to spin it or justify it any other way. Its weak. I don't care if you're doing it to shave off time or whatever. The game wasn't meant to be played that way.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 25, 2012, 05:57:37 AM
When you beat a game by using cheatcodes, save states, exploits, etc, its called cheating, so don't sit there trying to spin it or justify it any other way. Its weak. I don't care if you're doing it to shave off time or whatever. The game wasn't meant to be played that way.
No cheat codes are used. The idea isn't always to just "shave off time," its meant to entertain. A perfect example is or
And cheating... Who is being cheated? I'm not claiming these are real-time speedruns; that would be cheating. I'm explicitly stating these are Tool-Assisted. With that statement comes the understanding of the tools that were used.
Why do games only have to be played "the way they were meant to be played?" Would you get angry if a Lego kit were not put together like the instructions show? Video games are a toy, and TASes are just another way to play with them. Why does it make you so angry?
I get it, you don't like them. No one is forcing you to watch them.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Obfuscate on October 25, 2012, 06:55:33 AM
As long as you admit it I have no problem with tool assisted. It bugs me when you see a Youtube playthrough you know the did and they don't specify. I have no interest in tool assisted but I also have no interest in making videos either.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 06:57:48 AM
It doesn't make me angry idiot, so don't go fishing for non-existent emotions regarding the subject. Using any type of "tools" not originally present in the gameplay, intended by the programmers to be utilized in normal game play, to clear a game, is cheating, regardless of your intentions for the video. Just because you somehow decided to make yourself unemotionally invested in the process of clearing the game, playing it like a robot programmed for one straight task, editing out all mistakes in your game play, doesn't make the cheat any less significant. Just because you label it as something other then a normal game clear doesn't mean its still not a game clear. You still cleared the game, but you cheated to do it. You are clearing the game in a fashion that uses methods of bypassing the challenges that were presented before you. The whole point of the game is lost due to this. And yeah, no one is forcing me to watch them, and I don't. Using games and Legos as a comparison to justify the such as not being cheating is idiotic. Legos are a form of model, not a game.
Quote
Why do games only have to be played "the way they were meant to be played?"
I never said they had to be. You can cheat all damn day for all I care with your emulation, save states, etc. But cheating to win, for the goal of shaving off time or whatever, I don't care the reasoning behind it, doesn't make you a better player, it just makes you a weak hack. You want to do a video specifically to show exploits in a stage, fine. But don't go bragging about how you cleared a game in 5-20 mins after using save states and other exploits and whatever else, and act like you faced some godly challenge even worth mentioning. There is NOTHING cool or impressive about that. You should just call the videos what they really are. Cheat/save state assisted speed runs. You call it TAS because it sounds nicer on paper. Its whitewashing your game play.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Arkhan on October 25, 2012, 07:04:38 AM
Tool Assisted = cheating.
Especially when the tools involved allow you to pass through portions of a game frame by frame, see things you shouldn't see, rewind when you f*ck up, and dick around with things you weren't intended to dick around with.
That's cheating.
You don't experience the game as intended if you do that. They exist as a laugh. "Hey look how megaman just flew through the walls and flung himself around! That's funny!"
Watch the Wizardry TAS. Tell me that's really experiencing the game.
45 seconds of gameplay, totally experiencing the thrills and chills of the proving grounds of the mad overlord. Totally.
EDIT: I had to graph paper my way through that f*cking game, and got pissed when my wizard got decapitated. That's experiencing wizardry.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Arkhan on October 25, 2012, 07:26:32 AM
Dr.Professor, if you're not angry, why are you calling people idiots and beating a dead horse about the morality of TAS?
Cheating on spouse = bad Cheating on tests = bad Cheating in sports = bad Cheating on 1 player video game for own amusement = huh? who cares.
Nobody said "holy geez, I'm the best at teh vidya games 'cos I is so 1337".
I've never even dabbled in TAS personally. I only said that it was interesting and that liked the videos and would like to give it a try sometime... then you come in and start acting like someone depicted the Prophet Muhammed at a mosque. What is it about this forum? I've been a TG16 fan since the thing came out and was excited to find an active community of other fans, but so far the confrontational opinion police have swooped in to attack nearly every post I've made.
WTF are you going on about. I did not call "people" idiots. My last couple of post don't even address you for one, and were not a reply to you. The idiot was the clown trying to fish for non-existent emotions. Well, ok, maybe there is two idiots here on this thread, him and you. Instead of questioning and calling out the entire forum over its supposedly confrontational behavior you seem to dislike, you should learn to read a thread conversation better and check who the statements are addressing, and why they were made. It involves more then just yourself more often then not.
Better still, don't go comparing it to crazed attacks over religious matters that don't even concern me or anyone else here. There are plenty of people here of different religious backgrounds, and non-religious both. That is a none issue here, and that statement was not only in poor taste, because serious terror attacks do happen over things like that concerning peoples tolerance towards others religions, but also, it's moot because it has ZERO to do with the subject being discussed here. God, Jesus, Muhammed, ENIAC, Cthulhu and crew having nothing to do with anything being said here.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: nodtveidt on October 25, 2012, 07:57:07 AM
TAS videos are cool. If you don't like them, that's cool too. Opinions are like a$$holes... you know the rest.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Jibbajaba on October 25, 2012, 08:09:49 AM
What is it about this forum? I've been a TG16 fan since the thing came out and was excited to find an active community of other fans, but so far the confrontational opinion police have swooped in to attack nearly every post I've made.
Maybe because you have 15 posts and you're already trying to argue with forum regulars. Have some respect. Lurk for awhile, get to know people by reading their posts, and generally try to stay out of arguments until you have at least a small reputation as a basically good forum member. Trying to make a name for yourself by interjecting yourself into forum arguments with the regulars is not a good way to integrate yourself into the community.
Chris
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Jibbajaba on October 25, 2012, 08:19:48 AM
Ah f*ck it, I don't want to get involved.
Chris
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: nodtveidt on October 25, 2012, 08:29:52 AM
What is it about this forum? I've been a TG16 fan since the thing came out and was excited to find an active community of other fans, but so far the confrontational opinion police have swooped in to attack nearly every post I've made.
Maybe because you have 15 posts and you're already trying to argue with forum regulars. Have some respect. Lurk for awhile, get to know people by reading their posts, and generally try to stay out of arguments until you have at least a small reputation as a basically good forum member. Trying to make a name for yourself by interjecting yourself into forum arguments with the regulars is not a good way to integrate yourself into the community.
Chris
Chris, I'm not trying to argue with anyone but I appreciate your response and attempt to help me fit in. I had lurked for a while. I have not been disrespectful intentionally, but I do not tolerate disrespect very well... I understand respect is earned whereas disrespect can be had freely. How long must one lurk, and how many times must one bite their tongue before integration is achieved? In this thread, all I said was that I thought the TAS vids were cool, then I get tag teamed by people who disagree and gradually escalated the conversation to flames.
I'm still hopeful that I'll find this to be a community I want to integrate with as there are so many interesting conversations going on between people who seem to be genuinely nice. I used to run a large forum/IRC so I know how difficult it can be for someone new to the scene to be accepted, but at the same time I do not feel obligated to just sit silently when someone with a higher post count decides to disagree with me. It is kind of disappointing to me because sometimes it happens to be people who I'd pegged as cool after having reading their other posts.
I agree with nullity; just because a person has been here longer doesn't mean that they're right about everything. If new users, who appear to be willing to be competent upstanding members of the forum, are going to be flamed just for disagreeing with a vet of the forum, why not just merge with the neo-geo forums? :roll:
Seriously, just let people have their fun trying to make games their b*tch. If you don't appreciate it, fine. Just don't get your panties in a bunch over someone disagreeing with you on it.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Arkhan on October 25, 2012, 08:48:44 AM
You did call DK an idiot, and I chose to respond you your post. You don't have to address me to elicit a response when we're all discussing the same thing- which is how upset you seem to get when people have an opinion that differs from your own. I'll also respond to your claim that DK "is fishing for non-existent emotions"- you make no sense. Perhaps you should re-read his posts and compare the tone against your own posts and look for the difference. You may spot the emotions. His were polite, whereas yours were full of verbal chest-puffing.
DK is not more then one person. You stated I called "people" idiots. People being plural. Anyone going around claiming people are experiencing non-existent emotions over trivial shit like cheating in game clears IS a idiot for not simply taking the comment for what it is, expressing a opinion. Calling someone a idiot for doing the such is not "verbal chest-puffing", its stating a fact. Calling someone a cheater for using save states, hacks, cheat codes, etc to clear a game is not "verbal chest-puffing", or being emotional either. Again, its stating fact.
While it perhaps wasn't in the best taste, I stand by my Muhammed metaphor, which I shall explain now since it seems to have gone over your head and hit your religious tolerance centers instead of your rationality and self reflection center:
Your reaction is out of proportion to the offense you are reacting to; at least to those who do not share your views or opinions.
My reaction was stating a fact. I'm not going to butter the guy up with bullshit and lie to him and tell him he did some great thing, some huge accomplishment, when he in fact did not. Your metaphor as you'd like to put it, has no bearing at all on the content of the conversation. I did not make threats on his life, call his family disparaging names, torch his house, or threaten to time travel to 2062 and rape his grandkids. I called him a cheater, for cheating on a game, and a idiot, for making false claims about my emotional state about the subject, the same as you are doing. Cheat on games, you're a cheater. Say stupid shit, you're a idiot. That too hard a concept for you to grasp?
I'd wager you're not even really a professor. So, following the example of your reaction to TAS videos being advertised and posted as TAS videos: How dare you claim to be a professor when you're not one... roar! People should go about getting that title the honest way!
Again, you are a idiot. http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Professor%20Professorson
As for your assertation that I've called out and generalized the whole community as being confrontational, you're mistaken. What I said is that so far, almost every post I've made has been responded to in a hostile and confrontational manner. Look at my post count... mathematically, it is unlikely that I've spoken with everyone. You can point the finger at me all you want, but you and a few of the other members are the ones being irrational and rude. Can't blame me for not responding kindly to that.
You stated specifically " What is it about this forum?". The moment you stated that, you spoke of, and addressed, the community as a whole when stating your complaint. So, as you stated, mathematically, its not only unlikely, but also impossible you have had a confrontation with the majority of this forum. Therefore, you should not be starting your verbal complaints with "what is it about this forum?", for obvious reasons. Sorry you cant seem to grasp that.
Btw, I'm not only not a professor, I'm not a pawnbroker either. For serious.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 09:02:38 AM
What is it about this forum? I've been a TG16 fan since the thing came out and was excited to find an active community of other fans, but so far the confrontational opinion police have swooped in to attack nearly every post I've made.
Maybe because you have 15 posts and you're already trying to argue with forum regulars. Have some respect. Lurk for awhile, get to know people by reading their posts, and generally try to stay out of arguments until you have at least a small reputation as a basically good forum member. Trying to make a name for yourself by interjecting yourself into forum arguments with the regulars is not a good way to integrate yourself into the community.
Chris
Chris, I'm not trying to argue with anyone but I appreciate your response and attempt to help me fit in. I had lurked for a while. I have not been disrespectful intentionally, but I do not tolerate disrespect very well... I understand respect is earned whereas disrespect can be had freely. How long must one lurk, and how many times must one bite their tongue before integration is achieved? In this thread, all I said was that I thought the TAS vids were cool, then I get tag teamed by people who disagree and gradually escalated the conversation to flames.
I'm still hopeful that I'll find this to be a community I want to integrate with as there are so many interesting conversations going on between people who seem to be genuinely nice. I used to run a large forum/IRC so I know how difficult it can be for someone new to the scene to be accepted, but at the same time I do not feel obligated to just sit silently when someone with a higher post count decides to disagree with me. It is kind of disappointing to me because sometimes it happens to be people who I'd pegged as cool after having reading their other posts.
Here's all I'm saying.
Let's say that you move into a new neighborhood. And that neighborhood has a little local bar. So you're thinking, "cool, that'll be a cool place to hang out." So you go in, and predictably it's a bar full of neighborhood regulars who all know each other. So you go in there for a couple of days and try to integrate yourself into this little "community" of people who really only know each other because they've all been hanging out in the same bar forever. Being comfortable with each other, they give each other shit ("how's your wife and my kids"), get in the occasional drunken argument, buy each other beers, etc.
At this point, you basically have two options. Just start hanging out at the bar, slowly becoming a familiar face, being friendly to the regulars, etc. until you eventually become just another regular on the same level as everyone else. Or you could walk in there, have a few beers, and start acting the exact same way everyone else does as though you've been there forever. People are thinking "who the f*ck is this guy?", but since you haven't really done anything to offend anyone, you're tolerated. But then you push it too far. "Hey Bob, nice shirt. Didn't they have it in your size? By the way, your wife left her bra at my place last night." Or let's just say that a few of the regulars get in to an argument over something. Politics, football, the best brand of shaving cream, whatever. You interject yourself into the discussion instead of just hanging back. Again "who the f*ck are you" will be the common thought amongst the regulars, and you'll have a harder time eventually becoming "just one of the guys." You finally give up, leave, and tell people that "it seemed like a cool place, but not very friendly to new customers."
This isn't just aimed at you, nullity, but basically any new members who instantly have problems with people here. Newbs basically need to learn to chill the f*ck out, and if someone gives you a little too much shit, you might just have to take it on the chin. Or at the very least, tell the person to f*ck off and leave it at that. Complaining that you're being attacked because you're a newb is the absolute WORST thing you can do.
Chris
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 25, 2012, 09:21:58 AM
It doesn't make me angry idiot, so don't go fishing for non-existent emotions regarding the subject. Using any type of "tools" not originally present in the gameplay, intended by the programmers to be utilized in normal game play, to clear a game, is cheating, regardless of your intentions for the video. Just because you somehow decided to make yourself unemotionally invested in the process of clearing the game, playing it like a robot programmed for one straight task, editing out all mistakes in your game play, doesn't make the cheat any less significant. Just because you label it as something other then a normal game clear doesn't mean its still not a game clear. You still cleared the game, but you cheated to do it. You are clearing the game in a fashion that uses methods of bypassing the challenges that were presented before you. The whole point of the game is lost due to this. And yeah, no one is forcing me to watch them, and I don't. Using games and Legos as a comparison to justify the such as not being cheating is idiotic. Legos are a form of model, not a game.
Quote
Why do games only have to be played "the way they were meant to be played?"
I never said they had to be. You can cheat all damn day for all I care with your emulation, save states, etc. But cheating to win, for the goal of shaving off time or whatever, I don't care the reasoning behind it, doesn't make you a better player, it just makes you a weak hack. You want to do a video specifically to show exploits in a stage, fine. But don't go bragging about how you cleared a game in 5-20 mins after using save states and other exploits and whatever else, and act like you faced some godly challenge even worth mentioning. There is NOTHING cool or impressive about that. You should just call the videos what they really are. Cheat/save state assisted speed runs. You call it TAS because it sounds nicer on paper. Its whitewashing your game play.
I don't mean to attribute emotions to you, and I never once called you an idiot. Your posts just appear to be very emotional in tone, I don't know how you can't see that.
I've heard your argument before. I never understood why people feel like TASes take something away from their own personal experience with a game. People almost feel attacked by these runs, and they get very emotional about it. These runs aren't meant to be compared to a normal playthrough, or even demonstrate one. They are meant for something completely different. I disagree with the notion that they replace the experience of a game.
Does the game retain its normal challenge with TASing tools? Of course not. Instead, it is a different challenge - how do I make do with less? Less leveling in RPGs, less power ups in action games, less time in general? TASing will never make you a better player at the game, but who ever said that was the goal?
We call them "Save state assisted runs." Except Savestate is just one of the tools. I've looked at the assembly of games to help me better TAS them, written programming scripts, written brute-force bots, and many other tools.
Anyway, I don't see this discussion going anywhere, and this topic was pretty well covered 6 years ago (http://m2k2.taigaforum.com/post/the_problem_with_tas_and_a_solution.html). We aren't calling them cheat runs, because they aren't. That thread covers the both the pro and con, and comes to a nice consensus.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: vestcoat on October 25, 2012, 09:35:17 AM
What is it about this forum? I've been a TG16 fan since the thing came out and was excited to find an active community of other fans, but so far the confrontational opinion police have swooped in to attack nearly every post I've made.
Don't take it personally, Nullity. The reason you're running into strong language is because two-thirds of your posts have been in Gouging Much or a discussion with Professorson. Everyone not on the level gets barked at in Gounging Much. Prof is a stand-up guy, this is just how he argues. Some people don't like TAS's because it's not how the games were intended to be played. IMO, any gameplay video without a shaky camera and the voice of a youtube critic is A-OK.
You've only interacted with a handful of people. Post whatever you want. Stay on topic and nobody cares. Nothing short of a serious bender or some gouging in the sale forum will make a lasting impression around here.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 10:00:05 AM
a lot of crap and We aren't calling them cheat runs, because they aren't. That thread covers the both the pro and con, and comes to a nice consensus.
Yeah, and red is black, those cats lounging on your porch are really turtles, and the moon is actually a giant block of tasty cheddar f*cking cheese. WTF ever. A small league of supercheaters convene on a thread for a roundtable discussion taking place in the hopes of convincing their selves, and the world by proxy, that they are not really cheaters, and pat their selves on the back for doing such a great job of it and expect the rest of the world to buy it by linking to their discussion whenever these issues arise. Yeah, that totally not makes them cheaters, just like The Legion of Super-Villains would totally not be comprised of super villains after they decided to gather round for a roundtable discussion on how robbing the world bank or blowing up Hoover Dam or plotting to destroy JLA wasn't really evil or nuthin, and needed to be done for the betterment of mankind, declaring themselves to actually be superheros, then broadcasting a message worldwide stating the such, right? :roll:
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 25, 2012, 10:11:51 AM
Yeah, and red is black, those cats lounging on your porch are really turtles, and the moon is actually a giant block of tasty cheddar f*cking cheese. WTF ever. A small league of supercheaters convene on a thread for a roundtable discussion taking place in the hopes of convincing their selves, and the world by proxy, that they are not really cheaters, and pat their selves on the back for doing such a great job of it and expect the rest of the world to buy it by linking to their discussion whenever these issues arise. Yeah, that totally not makes them cheaters, just like The Legion of Super-Villains would totally not be comprised of super villains after they decided to gather round for a roundtable discussion on how robbing the world bank or blowing up Hoover Dam or plotting to destroy JLA wasn't really evil or nuthin, and needed to be done for the betterment of mankind, declaring themselves to actually be superheros, then broadcasting a message worldwide stating the such, right? :roll:
This is a reasonable, unemotional response, and demonstrates you clearly opened that link, and didn't make blanket assumptions about its content.
I mean, its not like the first page is someone laying out how TASes should be labelled as cheating for the good of all mankind.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Arjak on October 25, 2012, 10:13:24 AM
How DARE someone have fun doing something I don't approve of! Everyone should see things in black and white terms just like ME! If you have fun trying to break the rules of gaming in a way that doesn't hurt anyone, you're WORSE THAN HITLER! I'm going to call you names because I disapprove of something you're doing that has nothing to do with me!
Fixed for ya. :roll:
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Obfuscate on October 25, 2012, 10:23:45 AM
Yeah, and red is black, those cats lounging on your porch are really turtles, and the moon is actually a giant block of tasty cheddar f*cking cheese. WTF ever. A small league of supercheaters convene on a thread for a roundtable discussion taking place in the hopes of convincing their selves, and the world by proxy, that they are not really cheaters, and pat their selves on the back for doing such a great job of it and expect the rest of the world to buy it by linking to their discussion whenever these issues arise. Yeah, that totally not makes them cheaters, just like The Legion of Super-Villains would totally not be comprised of super villains after they decided to gather round for a roundtable discussion on how robbing the world bank or blowing up Hoover Dam or plotting to destroy JLA wasn't really evil or nuthin, and needed to be done for the betterment of mankind, declaring themselves to actually be superheros, then broadcasting a message worldwide stating the such, right? :roll:
This is a reasonable, unemotional response, and demonstrates you clearly opened that link, and didn't make blanket assumptions about its content.
I mean, its not like the first page is someone laying out how TASes should be labelled as cheating for the good of all mankind.
Actually I did look at it, for like a min or two, and I never stated TAS supporters started the thread. I stated they convened on it, which in itself is hilarious (Do you not know what the definition of convened is?). Am I going to read 10 pages of bullshit and counterpoint, accusations, arguments, whitewash, and spin about cheating on speedruns and why its ok or not ok? No, I'm not.
And Arjak, yeah, that's totally what I meant to say. Thanks for fixing all that for me. I was like totally having trouble putting it all in the right wording. Thank god for people like you, ready to put on that shining armor, gallop in on that white steed, step up, and stuff words in peoples mouths. For serious. :roll:
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 25, 2012, 10:57:09 AM
Actually I did look at it, for like a min or two, and I never stated TAS supporters started the thread. I stated they convened on it, which in itself is hilarious (Do you not know what the definition of convened is?). Am I going to read 10 pages of bullshit and counterpoint, accusations, arguments, whitewash, and spin about cheating on speedruns and why its ok or not ok? No, I'm not.
So basically, You never had any intentions of considering that hey, maybe TAS runs aren't cheating. Gotcha.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 10:58:18 AM
Actually I did look at it, for like a min or two, and I never stated TAS supporters started the thread. I stated they convened on it, which in itself is hilarious (Do you not know what the definition of convened is?). Am I going to read 10 pages of bullshit and counterpoint, accusations, arguments, whitewash, and spin about cheating on speedruns and why its ok or not ok? No, I'm not.
So basically, You never had any intentions of considering that hey, maybe TAS runs aren't cheating. Gotcha.
Why would I lie to myself like that? I'd rather not live in denial.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Jibbajaba on October 25, 2012, 11:19:55 AM
Thanks for the post, vestcoat. I wish 2/3 of my posts weren't in those two threads, but, you know. Gotta respond to responses. I'll sew some seeds in other threads and see what grows. I'll always be respectful of others' opinions, but never back down from my own unless they change... which of course is why most people express those things in the first place.
Oh, and JibbaJabba, I like your analogy. I don't think it is perfectly applicable to the forums or the context of my odyssey here thus far, but I get it and appreciate the effort.
See dude? With an attitude like that, you'll be just fine around here. Just keep your head down and your chin up. Philosophically speaking, since physically that's impossible.
Chris
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: glazball on October 25, 2012, 11:45:53 AM
Well DK, you said elsewhere no one said a word about your TAS's and now look! hehe
For years now, I thought that video of Super Mario 3's last level, where the player is jumping from one baddie to the next with insane precision was the work of some incredibly awesome Japanese dude who had been playing the shit out of it for years. Now I'm crushed to know it was a TAS. I don't do emulation so TAS's were new to me. Thanks for sharing.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: nodtveidt on October 25, 2012, 11:59:14 AM
Who cares if a TAS is cheating? The whole point of gaming is to have fun. If it's fun, who gives a smurf sausage?
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 25, 2012, 01:38:56 PM
And Arjak, yeah, that's totally what I meant to say. Thanks for fixing all that for me. I was like totally having trouble putting it all in the right wording. Thank god for people like you, ready to put on that shining armor, gallop in on that white steed, step up, and stuff words in peoples mouths. For serious. :roll:
No problem. If you have any difficulties with this in the future, let me know and I'll use my editorial skills to help out. :twisted:
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Sparky on October 25, 2012, 06:38:47 PM
When you beat a game by using cheatcodes, save states, exploits, etc, its called cheating, so don't sit there trying to spin it or justify it any other way. Its weak. I don't care if you're doing it to shave off time or whatever. The game wasn't meant to be played that way.
No cheat codes are used. The idea isn't always to just "shave off time," its meant to entertain. A perfect example is adelikat's gradius (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hETRzNzpFAI) or Baxter's Tetris. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ly-FQRS2Q0Y)
And cheating... Who is being cheated? I'm not claiming these are real-time speedruns; that would be cheating. I'm explicitly stating these are Tool-Assisted. With that statement comes the understanding of the tools that were used.
Why do games only have to be played "the way they were meant to be played?" Would you get angry if a Lego kit were not put together like the instructions show? Video games are a toy, and TASes are just another way to play with them. Why does it make you so angry?
I get it, you don't like them. No one is forcing you to watch them.
Darkobold this is the over reacting you do that gets you in trouble, prof only disagreed and said a few points and then the shit storm happened.... Accuse him of being angry? Hahaha.. Wow you need to grow some thicker skin around here and take some criticism
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: HercTNT on October 25, 2012, 06:56:15 PM
Don't TASe me bro..............
:mrgreen:
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Drakon on October 26, 2012, 02:04:08 AM
I love both skill runs and tas runs. I can appreciate them both for what they are. I don't mind if tas is cheating I still find it entertaining to watch. I think it's fun to see how much you can mess with a game.
*reading more and editing this post the more I catch up on what was said*
Of course a tas is cheating, but it's still fun to watch. I don't think the idea of a tas video is to "cheat to win". The idea is to see the fastest inhumanly possible speed to beat a game would be.
I don't get why professor accuses darkobold of not enjoying improving on a real time speedrun. I don't think he ever said he doesn't enjoy doing speedruns, just because you make tas videos doesn't mean you don't also enjoy doing the real thing. That's quite a big assumption to make isn't it. Telling someone to spend their timing making something other than tas videos in his tas video thread is kind of pointless is it not? It's like....oh I don't know....a little bit of off topic trolling. Yes it's kind of stupid to say that making a tas video isn't cheating, but it's also stupid bashing tas videos in a tas video thread for the sake of. Nobody ever stated that making tas videos is a "huge accomplishment" they're just meant for entertainment.
I'm cool with continuing these arguments in fighting street as that's a great place to do so (and I'm glad we have it). If you want to "get the last laugh" and retort to my comments before continuing in fighting street that's cool. I just don't want to make this thread any more of a pointless mess than it is.
Here's a topic I started to move all the anger away (hopefully):
As for this whole argument, I'd rather be an "idiot" than an over-opinionated troll.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Arkhan on October 26, 2012, 02:38:30 AM
You can't be a troll if you're a regular.
duhr.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: glazball on October 26, 2012, 03:26:53 AM
Dammit, now I might be getting addicted to these TAS videos! Just watched the Punch-Out one last night, and I know it's emuation/cheating/yadda yadda but boy it's nice to see someone beat the SHIT out of Bald Bull in like 52 seconds! The Excitebike and Gradius vids are awesome too. It's like watching Billy Mitchell on crack play all those old games.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Tatsujin on October 26, 2012, 03:50:36 AM
Tas your mom in the wheelchair on the monolith.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 26, 2012, 04:23:40 AM
I love both skill runs and tas runs. I can appreciate them both for what they are. I don't mind if tas is cheating I still find it entertaining to watch. I think it's fun to see how much you can mess with a game.
*reading more and editing this post the more I catch up on what was said*
Of course a tas is cheating, but it's still fun to watch. I don't think the idea of a tas video is to "cheat to win". The idea is to see the fastest inhumanly possible speed to beat a game would be.
On the contrary, you are using every cheat possible to your advantage to make the fastest possible run, and beat others TAS releases. The point is to beat the other person and basically prove who is the bigger, badder, bestest cheater evah, though they wont call it that outright, because it doesn't sound as nice on paper.
I don't think he ever said he doesn't enjoy doing speedruns, just because you make tas videos doesn't mean you don't also enjoy doing the real thing. That's quite a big assumption to make isn't it.
Maybe he does enjoy constantly reloading save states over and over again after every minuet screw-up, and playing games in slow motion, etc. If so, I'm sorry, point of, and joy of, the game has been lost either way at this point.
Telling someone to spend their timing making something other than tas videos in his tas video thread is kind of pointless is it not? It's like....oh I don't know....a little bit of off topic trolling.
Asking why someone cant just improve on a original non-cheat speed run instead, and stating your own opinion on TAS is not in anyway telling anyone else what to do, and is definitely not trolling. Don't read into things. He has had his own opportunity to explain his stance in complete detail, etc also, and try to present a convincing case. He failed to do so, instead insisting others were angry, and insisting cheating isn't really cheating. This is a bit different to like when you trolled tech threads due to your deep seeded hatred for other techs or whatever personal dilemma you had going on, where in one in particular you went on a wild tangent, doing name calling, making false accusations, and lying, saying someone made statements they never made, constantly re-editing your post over and over ad nauseum, simply because you couldn't get your insult worded just right... Please, don't confuse the two, and don't try to pretend you are now some kind of benevolent, wise, worldly, all knowing member of the forum and come here stating how everyone else is in the wrong, because you "know better" and suddenly feel you are above it all.
Yes it's kind of stupid to say that making a tas video isn't cheating, but it's also stupid bashing tas videos in a tas video thread for the sake of. Nobody ever stated that making tas videos is a "huge accomplishment" they're just meant for entertainment.
On the contrary, people have made it out like its a major accomplishment. These videos used to crop up all the time under the guise that they were normal play throughs. How long have you actually been on the internet? Also, no one is bashing it for the sake of doing so. That is implying people are posting just to boost their post count or something. Expressing an opinion and questioning the reasoning behind using cheats and exploits is not just "bashing for the sake of doing so". Its posting with a purpose.
I'm cool with continuing these arguments in fighting street as that's a great place to do so (and I'm glad we have it). If you want to "get the last laugh" and retort to my comments before continuing in fighting street that's cool. I just don't want to make this thread any more of a pointless mess than it is.
No one cares wtf you are cool with. Who in the hell do you think you are exactly? And also, stop confusing debating the moral implications of cheating with a all out conflict. And no one said, or even suggested, this thread was pointless mess, other then you yourself. Kinda ironic, huh? The only people trying to carry out any real argument of some type seem to be the white knights rushing to the aid of some guy who failed to convince others that cheating in games is cool cause its called TAS, not cheating. Even more ironic is they are white knighting a guy who had no qualms about starting shit with multiple members in other threads, simply because they fail miserably when it comes to things like paying attention to forum activity on a regular basis.
As for this whole argument, I'd rather be an "idiot" than an over-opinionated troll.
The irony being you yourself are a over-opinionated troll who has been banned from another forum and had to even be dealt with here by some members because your ego got too big.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: _joshuaTurbo on October 26, 2012, 04:28:30 AM
Let's say that you move into a new neighborhood. And that neighborhood has a little local bar. So you're thinking, "cool, that'll be a cool place to hang out." So you go in, and predictably it's a bar full of neighborhood regulars who all know each other. So you go in there for a couple of days and try to integrate yourself into this little "community" of people who really only know each other because they've all been hanging out in the same bar forever. Being comfortable with each other, they give each other shit ("how's your wife and my kids"), get in the occasional drunken argument, buy each other beers, etc.
At this point, you basically have two options. Just start hanging out at the bar, slowly becoming a familiar face, being friendly to the regulars, etc. until you eventually become just another regular on the same level as everyone else. Or you could walk in there, have a few beers, and start acting the exact same way everyone else does as though you've been there forever. People are thinking "who the f*ck is this guy?", but since you haven't really done anything to offend anyone, you're tolerated. But then you push it too far. "Hey Bob, nice shirt. Didn't they have it in your size? By the way, your wife left her bra at my place last night." Or let's just say that a few of the regulars get in to an argument over something. Politics, football, the best brand of shaving cream, whatever. You interject yourself into the discussion instead of just hanging back. Again "who the f*ck are you" will be the common thought amongst the regulars, and you'll have a harder time eventually becoming "just one of the guys." You finally give up, leave, and tell people that "it seemed like a cool place, but not very friendly to new customers."
This isn't just aimed at you, nullity, but basically any new members who instantly have problems with people here. Newbs basically need to learn to chill the f*ck out, and if someone gives you a little too much shit, you might just have to take it on the chin. Or at the very least, tell the person to f*ck off and leave it at that. Complaining that you're being attacked because you're a newb is the absolute WORST thing you can do.
Chris
:clap: Truly words to live by. This should be pasted on the front of the forums!
I really have no opinion either way about the decision on whether a person should be posting videos of gameplay tool assisted or otherwise, but I personally see so many game playthroughs on youtube now that are just the games bare bones, I think I'd rather watch the gameplay untouched by tools. Sometimes they die, sometimes it's all in one life, the video looks just like if I were to pick up and play it. It's more legit and authentic, ya know?
Not to say it doesn't have it's audience out there, it's still cool to see more vids out there displaying turbografx. I just hope a guy doesn't watch a TAS turbob vid and think: "Oh man, I can fly through 'Shockman' in 11 minutes just like that guy!" Cause he'll be sorely disappointed. LOL
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 26, 2012, 05:59:40 AM
Now, I'm going to declare all further posts about TASes being cheating as off-topic in this thread. Since I started it, I need to do my best to keep this thread on topic, so only further posts stating that TASes are awesome, and not cheating are considered on-topic. That is the way things work around here, right ?
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Arkhan on October 26, 2012, 06:08:19 AM
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: SamIAm on October 26, 2012, 07:09:54 AM
DarkKobold, please keep making Turbo TAS videos. They're interesting, and people will watch them. Just not the Professor, apparently.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Drakon on October 26, 2012, 07:09:57 AM
I'm not the one causing sh#t in here, I was trying to move it away from here, I don't see you putting in any effort. Although I know that you have never and probably will never admit that you're ever wrong, about anything. This thread isn't the "do you think tas videos are good?" thread, you're completely off topic and just plain badmouthing his work. I don't consider myself above anyone, but I do find your posts to be ruining this thread. I love how when someone posts against what professor believes he labels it as "trolling" but when professor posts against what someone else believes it's "posting with a purpose!"
I don't know what darkkobold did in other threads but just because he did it to other members doesn't make it okay for you to do it to him.
In the words of others in this thread, Professor, STFU, please. Or even better, find something positive to post about instead of thread crapping. Your opinion is annoying and could have been worded much more nicely, but you like to prove the internet wrong. I don't see why you're so obsessed with proving your point anyway, did darkkobold hurt your feeling somehow and you feel it's your duty to be annoying in return?
The irony being you yourself are a over-opinionated troll who has been banned from another forum and had to even be dealt with here by some members because your ego got too big.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 26, 2012, 10:36:39 AM
No, sadly that isn't the way things work around here. Even if you totally disagree with whats being said, if it pertains specifically to the topic itself basically, and the mud hasn't been flinging so bad that people are being sent home crying, then its still on target. To try to kick others out simply because you disagree with what they say, because they wont hero worship you, wont fly. This is a bit of a different situation compared to just jumping into like the ebay gouging thread and going out of your way to pick fights with people, then carrying that feud over specifically to FS in the hopes of continuing it.
If you really don't like what someone says, you can always hit ignore, but to be honest, by your own words, you already seemed to be aware that TAS was a hotly debated topic on other forums, so you should have expected some critical responses towards it when starting this thread here too. That does not mean you should not have started the thread though. It's great debate material, and it keeps the forum fresh. Do you realize just how boring every subject would be if every single person agreed on it and no one had differing opinions? Then everyone would basically say the exact same thing. There would be no interesting content to read.
This thread isn't the "do you think tas videos are good?" thread, you're completely off topic and just plain badmouthing his work. I don't consider myself above anyone, but I do find your posts to be ruining this thread. I love how when someone posts against what professor believes he labels it as "trolling" but when professor posts against what someone else believes it's "posting with a purpose!"
You post your work like this, you will be open to criticism, same as you would if you posted art in a gallery, or a short story online. Its a bit different posting a speed run involving cheating in gameplay, and going and thread crapping on tech threads like you did. Not actually being critical of the actual work posted, because it was correct to begin with, and you had no way to help improve upon it, but actually just aiming to prevent or discourage others from learning how to do tech work, because of your inflated ego.
What was it, something about you feeling that if someone cant read a sloppy messy schematic like the one you did, then you feel they shouldn't be doing soldering work to begin with, because they will ruin their expensive hardware, and you want to protect their investment, by taking a blow torch to the back of their Nes and carving out a sloppy mouse hole and filling it with a ton of hot glue? Oh, and lets not forget complaining about pics being used as a example for educational purposes, with no names mentioned, and you making a public spectacle of yourself over it, stating you'd never do something like that, only to find out you did exactly that yourself, and worse, by calling people out by name specifically in same lame attempt to trash their rep.
I don't know what darkkobold did in other threads but just because he did it to other members doesn't make it okay for you to do it to him.
This is a odd point to address. I mean, by stating this, that basically means you yourself should have STFU during the Xray event, and prior ones, and any other future conflict that comes to mind, instead of jumping in as you saw fit. You cant pick and choose like that, otherwise it just makes you a hypocrite. And also, I got nothing against him. I have not tossed disparaging remarks towards his family, called him a slew of names, etc. His feud with someone else is exactly that, his feud with someone else. I'm sure he's a big boy too, I doubt he really needs you lamely attempting to rescue him. If nothing else, you are doing him a disservice considering your own rep as it is, in some ways in a effort to make the situation more about yourself and your own shortcomings then about TAS itself and the criticism surrounding it.
In the words of others in this thread, Professor, STFU, please. Or even better, find something positive to post about instead of thread crapping. Your opinion is annoying and could have been worded much more nicely, but you like to prove the internet wrong. I don't see why you're so obsessed with proving your point anyway, did darkkobold hurt your feeling somehow and you feel it's your duty to be annoying in return?
Yeah, bout that, you care to quote every post concerning me where someone had stated STFU? Just because a opinion is annoying to you (because of you're secret admiration/hate thing you have going for me) doesn't make it thread crapping, if its pertinent to the subject matter. You'll just have to learn to deal with others opinions here Drakon, even if you don't like said person, just like how you'll have to learn to deal with the fact that as a modder, your status here is the lowest on the totem pole here possibly, due to the sloppiness of your work, which is sad, because you have the smarts.
If it makes you feel any better, you can always go back to your own forum and verbally trash others work again, calling them out by name, knowing full well more likely then not said people will never see you talking shit about them behind their back. Or you could suck it up, practice harder, and put out some real quality stuff on a consistent basis instead of ragging on others work in a effort to make you feel better about your own shortcomings. You could also learn to bite your tongue and learn to accept peoples advice in said work a little better. It will help prevent you from being banished from yet another forum.
The irony being you yourself are a over-opinionated troll who has been banned from another forum and had to even be dealt with here by some members because your ego got too big.
DarkKobold, please keep making Turbo TAS videos. They're interesting, and people will watch them. Just not the Professor, apparently.
Myself and others, yeah, but hey, lets keep pretending the forum is made up entirely only of 7 people, and one of them is me, and the other 6 totally disagree with me on every level. :roll:
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 26, 2012, 11:21:26 AM
No, sadly that isn't the way things work around here. Even if you totally disagree with whats being said, if it pertains specifically to the topic itself basically, and the mud hasn't been flinging so bad that people are being sent home crying, then its still on target
I realize this, it was a subtle jab at the gouging thread. I simply said to Bigus that it was silly to call a specific auction gouging. That brought the hellfire. Funny how you can disagree and post here that TASes are cheating, but I can't post disagreeing that a specific auction is not, in fact, gouging.
If you really don't like what someone says, you can always hit ignore, but to be honest, by your own words, you already seemed to be aware that TAS was a hotly debated topic on other forums, so you should have expected some critical responses towards it when starting this thread here too. That does not mean you should not have started the thread though. It's great debate material, and it keeps the forum fresh. Do you realize just how boring every subject would be if every single person agreed on it and no one had differing opinions? Then everyone would basically say the exact same thing. There would be no interesting content to read.
I find it amazing that you have all the sudden become eloquent, and use the word "debate."
The part of my post you didn't respond to shows you had no intention of even considering my side. That doesn't make for a productive debate. That makes for a screaming match. If you are actually interested in having an intellectual debate over the merits of TASes, I'm always up for it. Screaming Cheater Cheater Cheater is not in anyway interesting.
No, sadly that isn't the way things work around here. Even if you totally disagree with whats being said, if it pertains specifically to the topic itself basically, and the mud hasn't been flinging so bad that people are being sent home crying, then its still on target
I realize this, it was a subtle jab at the gouging thread. I simply said to Bigus that it was silly to call a specific auction gouging. That brought the hellfire. Funny how you can disagree and post here that TASes are cheating, but I can't post disagreeing that a specific auction is not, in fact, gouging.
If you really don't like what someone says, you can always hit ignore, but to be honest, by your own words, you already seemed to be aware that TAS was a hotly debated topic on other forums, so you should have expected some critical responses towards it when starting this thread here too. That does not mean you should not have started the thread though. It's great debate material, and it keeps the forum fresh. Do you realize just how boring every subject would be if every single person agreed on it and no one had differing opinions? Then everyone would basically say the exact same thing. There would be no interesting content to read.
I find it amazing that you have all the sudden become eloquent, and use the word "debate."
The part of my post you didn't respond to shows you had no intention of even considering my side. That doesn't make for a productive debate. That makes for a screaming match. If you are actually interested in having an intellectual debate over the merits of TASes, I'm always up for it. Screaming Cheater Cheater Cheater is not in anyway interesting.
So basically, You never had any intentions of considering that hey, maybe TAS runs aren't cheating. Gotcha.
Why would I lie to myself like that? I'd rather not live in denial.
You instead compared me to Lex Luthor, when I clearly have way more hair than he does. Plus, I'd never steal 40 cakes. That is too many cakes.
If you are simply stating a certain auction is not gouging, that's one thing. Constantly interjecting yourself into a argument is another, and as explained prior, you have not really earned any rep here to be comfortable doing that. As far as the TAS goes, you have in fact made no such valid defense. You linked to someone elses defense, expecting people to read 10 pages worth of it. And just because there is 10 pages worth of people saying they are not cheating, does not make it suddenly not cheating. Save states are a cheat tactic. Playing games in slow mo are also a cheat tactic. Using stage exploits are also a cheat tactic. Using invincibility, also a cheat tactic.
You may not consider a TAS to be on the same level as a legitimate speed run, because you are purposely demonstrating how many rules in the game you can break to get to the finish line faster, and that's fine, because its not. But being able to acknowledged the such does not suddenly make the appliance of the word "cheat" null and void concerning the matter of using said cheats, nor justify calling it something other then what it actually is. You can rename them to "tools" all day long to make it sound better to you, but in reality, they will always be cheats, and any normal person would be able to acknowledged this without issue. I'm not going to whitewash it in order to make you feel better by calling it tools, because in most games you were already provided the tools necessary by means of which to win the game, via earning power-ups, maps, extra lives, etc. Call a spade a spade. Cheating is cheating, regardless of the goal, or the purpose of reaching it.
Oh yeah, also, I never compared you personally to Lex Luther, nor did I mention Lex specifically I believe for that matter. Actually, I compared the people in the thread you linked to to the The Legion of Super-Villains, of which Lex Luther was not a member of if I remember right, though he did collaborate with them. You read into it a bit too much there.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Necromancer on October 26, 2012, 11:51:24 AM
I fall in the group that has little interest in watching TAS videos and that the "tools" are most definitely cheats, but who cares? I ain't gonna watch 'em, nor do I care if the creators think they're cool for making 'em.
I realize this, it was a subtle jab at the gouging thread. I simply said to Bigus that it was silly to call a specific auction gouging. That brought the hellfire. Funny how you can disagree and post here that TASes are cheating, but I can't post disagreeing that a specific auction is not, in fact, gouging.
I'm not sure why I bother responding to such an obvious troll job, but anyways...
When you defined price gouging, you did not state that it applied solely to that one specific auction, thereby declaring that all auctions that start low but end at unreasonable prices can't possibly be gouge jobs. It's called semantics. Look it up some time.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 26, 2012, 12:19:19 PM
Save states are a cheat tactic. Playing games in slow mo are also a cheat tactic. Using stage exploits are also a cheat tactic. Using invincibility, also a cheat tactic.
TASes never use cheat codes. The end result is always just a stream of inputs, that theoretically could be put into the console, and play the game perfectly. In some cases, the
Also, you mention stage-exploits. The World-record Speedrun (not TAS) for Ocarina of Time is 25m27s. It warps from the first dungeon to the final battle using a corrupted pointer and corrupted inventory items. Is that also cheating to you?
You may not consider a TAS to be on the same level as a legitimate speed run, ....
We haven't, never have. Speedrunning is about practice, and honing a skill. The two are not comparable, for the most part. TASing is about planning, and making perfection, by finding the fastest possible, not the fastest possible for a human. They aren't on the same level, and comparing the results is not fair, beyond a supposed max limit for a human.
That said, many members of SpeedDemosArchive are members of TASVideos, and vice versa. I'm actually practicing Dungeon Explorer, and have gotten my time down to 27:30. The TAS of Dungeon Explorer in no way replaces the need for a speedrun, and vice-versa. They exist for totally different reasons.
But being able to acknowledged the such does not suddenly make the appliance of the word "cheat" null and void concerning the matter of using said cheats, nor justify calling it something other then what it actually is. You can rename them to "tools" all day long to make it sound better to you, but in reality, they will always be cheats, and any normal person would be able to acknowledged this without issue. I'm not going to whitewash it in order to make you feel better by calling it tools, because in most games you were already provided the tools necessary by means of which to win the game, via earning power-ups, maps, extra lives, etc. Call a spade a spade. Cheating is cheating, regardless of the goal, or the purpose of reaching it.
Your carebear picture, and other posts seem to say the same sentiment, repeatedly. Yes, a TAS is not a comparable playthrough, nor is it meant to represent one or feel like one. Its just a different challenge, a different way to play the game, which is actually quite a bit of fun. I can give an example, from a recent one I was playing with, Final Lap Twin.
Now, the goal of a TAS is to produce the shortest time. Thus, you want to have as few random encountered as possible. Additionally, you want to make the random encounters as productive as possible, which means fighting the enemy with the best returns. Now I had to figure out how random encounters worked (its a step counter, which decreases by 1 every step, and is reset to a random number every time you get an encounter.) I had to figure out how to beat the first enemy and boss with no upgrades (an impossible feat in real-time - you have to basically bump him off the road.) The end result of this test TAS was... meh. Not very interesting to watch, so I won't be continuing it. However, it was a fun time to make. It was fun to see how the internals of the game worked. It was fun seeing if I could beat the first boss with no upgrades, something I originally thought impossible.
A similar situation happens in Dragon Knight 3, which was my next planned TAS (I don't have much time for TASing these days). When you are in the first section, you can skip encounters by hitting zero on the step counter at the exact step you interact with a skeleton in the first cave. The planning for that isn't easy. It isn't at all comparable to the stuff you do for a speedrun. But it certainly is fun to do. It turns games into brain teasers.
I'm starting to realize, I don't really care if you call it cheating. It doesn't make them any less interesting, and if it helps you sleep at night, call'em whatever you want. TASVideos has enough people who enjoy them, that it is a thriving small community. No one there considers them cheating, and no one there considers them on the same level as speedrunning. No one in either the speedrunning community or the tasvideos community feels the way you do about TASes. Each has its place in the world, and we can all live in harmony, or some other hippy crap.
In short, I've had a blast trying to find the fastest way through a game. If you feel that is cheating, your choice. You are missing out on a cool and different perspective to games. Think outside the box.
Oh yeah, also, I never compared you to Lex Luther, nor did I mention Lex I believe. Actually, I compared the people in the thread you linked to to the The Legion of Super-Villains, of which Lex Luther was not a member of if I remember right, though he did collaborate with them. You read into it a bit too much there.
That was included just for joking purposes. You mentioned JLA, which includes Superman, so I assumed that Lex by default would be an enemy of JLA.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Jibbajaba on October 26, 2012, 01:37:39 PM
DK, please do us all a favor and shut the f*ck up. You want to post TAS videos? Do it. But if every post you make in every other thread is just going to be you arguing with the rest of us, then why bother?
I said it before and I'll say it again. Why can't we have like 2 f*cking weeks of peace around here without some new f*cking trolls or Internet tough guys showing up here, f*cking our shit up? Sorry if shit didn't go we'll for you here DK, but the net result of your presence here is that it makes PCEFX a slightly shittier place for those of us here who are on board with the way shit works.
Chris
Edit: Why do you even give a shit if the prof (and several more of us) thinks that your videos are cheating? Just like the fact that not everyone has to agree with him, not everyone has to agree with you. Not anyone HAS to get the last word in all the time. He thinks TASes are cheating, you don't, end of f*cking story. Instead of wasting time typing out 2000 word rebuttals to everything prof says, why don't you spend that time making videos for the people that enjoy your work?
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: DarkKobold on October 26, 2012, 01:56:18 PM
DK, please do us all a favor and shut the f*ck up. You want to post TAS videos? Do it. But if every post you make in every other thread is just going to be you arguing with the rest of us, then why bother?
I said it before and I'll say it again. Why can't we have like 2 f*cking weeks of peace around here without some new f*cking trolls or Internet tough guys showing up here, f*cking our shit up? Sorry if shit didn't go we'll for you here DK, but the net result of your presence here is that it makes PCEFX a slightly shittier place for those of us here who are on board with the way shit works.
Chris
Edit: Why do you even give a shit if the prof (and several more of us) thinks that your videos are cheating? Just like the fact that not everyone has to agree with him, not everyone has to agree with you. Not anyone HAS to get the last word in all the time. He thinks TASes are cheating, you don't, end of f*cking story. Instead of wasting time typing out 2000 word rebuttals to everything prof says, why don't you spend that time making videos for the people that enjoy your work?
Do you realize just how boring every subject would be if every single person agreed on it and no one had differing opinions? Then everyone would basically say the exact same thing. There would be no interesting content to read.
I don't go into threads with uninteresting topics (to me) and tell everyone to stop wasting their time, but I'd expect to get told off if I did.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Bernie on October 26, 2012, 01:57:04 PM
I cant believe that Super Mario 3 fast play through was a TAS, or whatever it is... :( Damn I loved watching that, and now I know it was all fake. :( My opinion on it, I dont really care one way or another. It may interest some, others it wont. If its a game I have already played through, I guess it would be neat watching somone do it, but other than that it would be a spoiler for me.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: nodtveidt on October 26, 2012, 06:17:03 PM
Maybe he does enjoy constantly reloading save states over and over again after every minuet screw-up, and playing games in slow motion, etc. If so, I'm sorry, point of, and joy of, the game has been lost either way at this point.
Doesn't really matter... one's enjoyment is another's torment. If you don't wanna make or watch a TAS, so be it... if someone else does want to, so be it. Both opinions are equally valid unto one's self but also equally irrelevant to the other. The topic of "cheating" comes up from time to time in the DOOM modding community, and the general consensus every time is "who the f*ck cares".
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: 420GOAT on October 26, 2012, 06:24:52 PM
its not for me but the saving feature is the best to some of my homies.
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: Drakon on October 27, 2012, 12:25:07 AM
You need to grow the f#ck up. All you ever do is go around trying to hurt me feelings because you're mr. perfect. You're just a non-stop cannon. Instead of focusing on every little mistake you can dig up on other people when was the last time you tried to improve yourself in any way? You derailed this thread with your cult following opinion, even if only a little, you did it, just please grow up and admit you made a mistake for once in your life.
I fall in the group that has little interest in watching TAS videos and that the "tools" are most definitely cheats, but who cares? I ain't gonna watch 'em, nor do I care if the creators think they're cool for making 'em. but end at unreasonable prices can't possibly be gouge jobs. It's called semantics. Look it up some time.
Now if professor had made his point this way, I don't think people would have minded. Thankyou necro for being respectful. Anyone who takes professor's comments harshly professor will continue labelling as a "pussy" without any consideration.
I said it before and I'll say it again. Why can't we have like 2 f*cking weeks of peace around here without some new f*cking trolls or Internet tough guys showing up here, f*cking our shit up? Sorry if shit didn't go we'll for you here DK, but the net result of your presence here is that it makes PCEFX a slightly shittier place for those of us here who are on board with the way shit works.
Chris
Edit: Why do you even give a shit if the prof (and several more of us) thinks that your videos are cheating? Just like the fact that not everyone has to agree with him, not everyone has to agree with you. Not anyone HAS to get the last word in all the time. He thinks TASes are cheating, you don't, end of f*cking story. Instead of wasting time typing out 2000 word rebuttals to everything prof says, why don't you spend that time making videos for the people that enjoy your work?
I really like darkkobold and his posts and his opinions. I agree he should have kept his opinions in a separate thread but if anything I think he makes this forum a better place. Darkkobold may have opinions and ways of appreciating the pc engine that the old forum members don't approve of but I'm sure we can find a way to get along peacefully which is all I've ever wanted.
Also please correct me if I'm wrong on this but sometimes I feel professor does the same 200 word retorts, and nobody is giving him a hard time about it.
Anyway....I'm looking forward to the next tas video. I'm hoping when it gets posted people don't say "why don't you spend your time doing something else?"
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: ProfessorProfessorson on October 27, 2012, 04:54:56 AM
Are you saying this to me, or do you really mean this for yourself? You act like a paranoid teenage drama queen, throwing a huge hissy fit when you feel you've been attacked, when you in fact were not. You then lie about someone flat out, multiple times. You gossip about and insult others on your own forum (a virtual podium of self-worship). You gossip and bitch about people to their friends in the hopes of turning them against each other. All of it, high school drama shit. You want to start shit and attack people and talk shit behind their backs, prepare for the possibility you'll get curb-stomped, either here or IRL. Chalk it up to a lesson learned. It'll be dropped when you drop it, and stop injecting yourself into more drama.
All you ever do is go around trying to hurt me feelings because you're mr. perfect. You're just a non-stop cannon. Instead of focusing on every little mistake you can dig up on other people when was the last time you tried to improve yourself in any way? You derailed this thread with your cult following opinion, even if only a little, you did it, just please grow up and admit you made a mistake for once in your life.
Also please correct me if I'm wrong on this but sometimes I feel professor does the same 200 word retorts, and nobody is giving him a hard time about it.
If you feel persecuted, maybe you should take a step back and realize you get what you ask for Nancy. You started your own mess. You cant deal with it, then hit the road. Don't pick unwarranted fights, find out you don't have what it takes to finish them, continually inject yourself into more conflicts anyway, then turn around, and cry about it like you are a victim when suddenly you realize you have no chance to survive the bullshit you brought upon yourself. Also, don't go crying about it to other peoples friends behind the scenes in the hopes that you can drag others into your conflict. No one here is going to be your little public life preserver bailing you out of every fight you start but suddenly find out you cant win. No one here is your little personal army either. Such a little drama queen, I swear.... :roll:
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: nodtveidt on October 27, 2012, 05:15:24 AM
Ain't this the pot calling the kettle black... :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
Being a king of the drama is a tad different my fine friend. The king never cries, retreats, and tries to drag others friends into the shit to do his bidding. :wink: Thats why the queen needs to stay in the kitchen, keep makin sammiches.
EDIT: Oh yeah, almost forgot, OVERRIDE IS f*ckING AWESOME!
Title: Re: My Tool-Assisted Speedruns (TAS) for Turbografx
Post by: esteban on October 27, 2012, 11:57:35 PM
First, thanks for bumping this topic, DarkKobold. (http://junk.tg-16.com/images/pcgs.png)
I actually remember when you initially posted it, but I was unable to watch any videos at the time (too busy catching up on stuff in the forum, same thing I'm doing now!).
Second, I'm not going to read all the drama.
Third, I'll post my comments on the actual topic (TG-16 TAS videos) in the near future.