I don't know anything about the new Splatterhouse but there's one thing I know about modern-day gaming in general... if your game isn't uber-complex to the teeth or marketed for braindead blowhards or "family", you're going to get low marks. Action games that don't need 100 buttons automatically get ridiculed nowadays. So if the new Splatterhouse is just good old fashioned carnage without a lot of button-work, then game magazines are going to be all kinds of stupid about it.