Which was my beef with them...
When I bought a loose Arcade Card Pro from them, the auction had a picture of a used looking, but not discolored arcade card pro.  I best offered and was accepted.  I got it in, saw how faded the label was and was slightly disappointed, but shrugged it off because of the low price.  Then when it failed to work I was a little more frustrated.  After going back and forth with hit japan over refund / exchange options, I sent the item back and received a refund after a few weeks.  So basically it cost me $4 - $5 for nothing at all.  Ok fine, you win some you lose some, I'm not going to gripe over $5.  What bothers me is that it seems pretty likely that they tried to resell that same card to kakuto here.  If they cant offer him a card in exchange, that tells me they dont have a pile of discolored arcade card pros laying around.  That tells me that the card he got was more than likely the same card they mailed me.
Edit:
Here's the auction I won: 
http://www.ebay.com/itm/360397170875Picture clearly isnt faded... and card condition stated as "B" lol